$415,000
New Buffalo, MI 49117
MLS# 26019566
4 beds | 2 baths | 2170 sqft
1 / 43
Open House (05/23/2026 - 1:00 pm - 3:00 pm)
Property Description
OPEN HOUSE 5/23 1PM-3PM - Welcome to 418 S Mayhew St. This New Buffalo home is just waiting for it's next chapter to begin. Set on an oversized lot, the layout offers a true three-bedroom, two-bath footprint, with additional upper-level space that can flex into a fourth bedroom, office, or private retreat. Truly a canvas for the way you want to live, this home is comfortable for everyday living and just as well-suited for hosting when friends and family come to town. The exterior adds to the appeal, with a large detached two-car garage and an expansive driveway that easily accommodates friends and family alike. With a location that's super convenient to New Buffalo Area School campuses, downtown, Amtrak, local trails, and the beach, this gem of a property is ideal for year-round living, or as your own personal retreat in the city of New Buffalo.
Details
Location & Property Info
Cross Streets: Clay
Property Sub-Type: Single Family Residence
Municipality: New Buffalo City
Office/Contract Info
Auction or For Sale: For Sale
List Price/SqFt: 191.24
General Property Info
New Construction: No
Lot Dimensions: 122 x 124
Road Frontage: 122
Garage Y/N: Yes
Garage Spaces: 2
Fireplace: Yes
Total Fireplaces: 1
Waterfront: No
Income Property: No
Basement: No
Total Rooms AG: 9
Total Fin SqFt All Levels: 2170
SqFt Above Grade: 2170
Below Grade Finished SqFt: 0
Below Grade Unfinished SqFt: 0
Building Total SqFt: 2170
Total Beds Above Grade: 4
Main Level Primary: Yes
Stories: 2
School District: New Buffalo
Association YN: No
Lot Measurement: Acres
Lot Acres: 0.35
Lot Square Footage: 15155
Year Built: 1950
Total Bedrooms: 4
Full Baths: 2
Total Baths: 2
Tax Info
Taxable Value: 88465
SEV: 194200
For Tax Year: 2024
Seller's Annual Property Tax: 2373
Tax Year: 2024
Homestead %: 100
Spec Assessment & Type: none known bta
Tax ID #: 11-62-8230-0003-00-4
Remarks & Misc
Public Remarks: OPEN HOUSE 5/23 1PM-3PM - Welcome to 418 S Mayhew St. This New Buffalo home is just waiting for it's next chapter to begin. Set on an oversized lot, the layout offers a true three-bedroom, two-bath footprint, with additional upper-level space that can flex into a fourth bedroom, office, or private retreat. Truly a canvas for the way you want to live, this home is comfortable for everyday living and just as well-suited for hosting when friends and family come to town. The exterior adds to the appeal, with a large detached two-car garage and an expansive driveway that easily accommodates friends and family alike. With a location that's super convenient to New Buffalo Area School campuses, downtown, Amtrak, local trails, and the beach, this gem of a property is ideal for year-round living, or as your own personal retreat in the city of New Buffalo.
Legal: LOTS 3 & 4 SUB OF PART OF BLK 221 VIRGINIA ADD TO VILLAGE OF NEW BUFFALO
Utilities Attached
Cable Connected: 1
High Speed Internet: 1
Natural Gas Connected: 1
Phone Connected: 1
Sewer
Public Sewer: 1
Water
Public: 1
Terms Available
Cash: 1
Conventional: 1
Laundry Features
In Hall: 1
Main Level: 1
Exterior Material
Stone: 1
Vinyl Siding: 1
Roofing
Composition: 1
Parking Features
Detached: 1
Heat Source
Natural Gas: 1
Sale Conditions
None: 1
Heat Type
Forced Air: 1
Air Conditioning
Central Air: 1
Access Feat
Accessibility Features: No
Upper Rooms
Upper Bedrooms: 1
Upper Level Square Feet: 390
Total Baths Above Grade: 2
Main Rooms
Main Bedrooms: 3
Main Full Baths: 2
Main Level SQFT: 1780
Lower Rooms
Lower Finished SQFT: 0
Total Lower SQFT: 0
Driveway
Gravel: 1
Substructure
Crawl Space: 1
Kitchen Features
Breakfast Nook: 1
Garden Window: 1
Fireplace
Family Room: 1
Patio and Porch Features
Deck: 1
Architectural Style
Ranch: 1
Possession
See Remarks: 1
Location Property Info
County: Berrien
Street #: 418
Street Direction: S
Street Name: Mayhew
Suffix: Street
State: MI
Zip Code: 49117
Zip (4): 1746
OfficeContract Info
Status: Active
List Price: $415,000
Current Price: $415,000
Listing Date: 2026-05-02
Remarks Misc
Directions: W Buffalo to Right on S Mayhew. Approx 5 blocks up on S Mayhew on Right.
Property Features
Laundry Features: In Hall; Main Level
Exterior Material: Stone; Vinyl Siding
Roofing: Composition
Substructure: Crawl Space
Sewer: Public Sewer
Water: Public
Utilities Attached: Cable Connected; High Speed Internet; Natural Gas Connected; Phone Connected
Kitchen Features: Breakfast Nook; Garden Window
Fireplace: Family Room
Heat Source: Natural Gas
Heat Type: Forced Air
Air Conditioning: Central Air
Patio and Porch Features: Deck
Parking Features: Detached
Architectural Style: Ranch
Driveway: Gravel
Terms Available: Cash; Conventional
Possession: See Remarks
Sale Conditions: None
Supplements
The lot itself provides space to spread out, garden, or simply enjoy the quiet surroundings. From here, it's just a few blocks to downtown New Buffalo, the high school community sports complex, nearby walking trails at the elementary school, and Lake Michigan access--close enough to enjoy it all, yet tucked into a neighborhood that feels removed from the pace. A well-loved home with flexibility, charm, and a location that continues to draw people in--ready for its next chapter.
Room Information
| Room Name | Length | Width | Level |
| Kitchen | 12.00 | 9.00 | Main |
| Dining Room | 14.00 | 10.00 | Main |
| Family Room | 16.00 | 23.00 | Main |
| Living Room | 11.00 | 9.00 | Main |
| Bedroom 2 | 11.00 | 13.00 | Main |
| Bedroom 3 | 11.00 | 19.00 | Main |
| Bedroom 4 | 23.00 | 15.00 | Main |
Listing Office: @properties Christie's International R.E.
Listing Agent: Elizabeth Roch
Last Updated: May - 23 - 2026
The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the MLS of MICHRIC , and site contains live data. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.